MemoryBox vs LegacyBox: Complete 2024 Comparison Guide
An honest, detailed comparison of two popular digitizing services based on real customer experiences and quality analysis.
When it comes to digitizing your precious family memories, choosing the right service can make all the difference. Two names that frequently come up in this space are LegacyBox and MemoryBox by DigMyPics. But which one actually delivers better results?
After analyzing hundreds of customer reviews, comparing service features, and examining actual output quality, we've put together this comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision.
Quick Comparison Overview
| Feature | MemoryBox | LegacyBox |
|---|---|---|
| Years in Business | 20+ years (since 2002) | 11 years (since 2013) |
| Color Correction | ✓ Included | ✗ Not Available |
| Formats Accepted | All Formats | Limited (35mm only) |
| Typical Turnaround | 15-20 days | 3-4 months |
| Real-Time Tracking | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
Quality: The Most Important Factor
MemoryBox Quality Advantages
- Professional Color Correction: Every photo and film frame is manually reviewed and color-corrected by skilled preservation artists
- Dust and Scratch Removal: Included at no extra cost for all photos
- Multiple Format Support: Handles virtually all slide and negative formats, not just 35mm
- Individual Attention: Each item receives personal care rather than assembly-line processing
LegacyBox Quality Limitations
- No Enhancement Services: LegacyBox's own customer service confirms they provide "no color correction or photo restoration"
- Limited Format Support: Only scans 35mm slides and negatives; other formats are returned unscanned
- Assembly-Line Approach: High volume processing (700,000 items per week) means less individual attention
- Basic Transfer Method: Uses simple "1:1 transfer" method rather than professional scanning techniques
Real Customer Experiences
MemoryBox Customer Review
"This is the second time I've submitted media after doing a direct comparison with LegacyBox. DigMyPics outdid LegacyBox on every front – even a better price! The wonderful quality on slides, 8mm film, and VHS... Send all your precious media to them – you'll get it back in great condition."
- J. Corona, Ben Lomond, CACommon LegacyBox Complaints
- Long delays (3-4 months vs. promised timeframes)
- Poor customer service and communication
- Items returned as "unconvertible" without proper explanation
- No enhancement or quality improvement services
- Hidden limitations on accepted formats
Service & Support Comparison
MemoryBox Service
- Real-time project tracking
- Preview videos and photos online as they're processed
- Direct communication with technicians
- Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
- Multiple rescue attempts for problematic media
- 20+ years of experience and expertise
LegacyBox Service
- Limited project updates
- No preview capability
- Call center customer service
- Potential for surprise charges
- Quick dismissal of "problematic" items
- Newer company with less experience
Pricing: Value for Money
While both services offer competitive pricing, the value proposition differs significantly:
- MemoryBox: Includes color correction, dust removal, and enhancement services for all photo and film formats
- LegacyBox: Basic transfer service with different enhancement options available
As one customer noted: "DigMyPics outdid LegacyBox on every front – even a better price!"
The Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Based on our analysis, MemoryBox by DigMyPics emerges as the clear winner for customers who prioritize:
- Superior quality with professional enhancement
- Comprehensive format support
- Faster turnaround times
- Transparent communication and tracking
- Experienced, caring service
Ready to Experience the MemoryBox Difference?
Join thousands of satisfied customers who chose quality over marketing hype.
Start Your Project Today